I have a bricks and mortar liquor store. We have used traditional credit card merchant processing for five years, and we just switched over to Square. I’ll tell you why we converted and how we did it.
Our Old “Traditional” Merchant Processing
 |
| Yes, I really do have a liquor store. |
Our traditional merchant was Retriever Payment Systems, “powered by” NPC (National Processing Company). We’d been with them for just over five years. When I opened my October statement, there was another new fee on my account. It was one fee too far. I called and talked to customer service at NPC, and on that call, I decided to find a new processor.
Our qualified rate was 1.55%. (I see that their website is offering rates as low as 1.35% today.) Sounds fine, but it doesn’t take into account the other fees we paid. So I added up all the fees, and divided by the total amount processed. That gave me a total effective cost of 3.1% to 3.3% for my processing. (It varies, depending on the transactions for the month.)
We also leased a credit card terminal, arranged by the Retriever salesman, through Lease Finance Group, LLC., paying $35.67 per month. I was more than ready to eliminate that lease and put that money towards acquiring some new equipment.
Square Processing
I have been familiar with Square for three years, through another of my businesses. Not too long ago, they changed their rate structure to be just a straight percentage, with no other fees. The fee is 2.75% for card-swiped transactions. That’s all we do at the store, so that fit perfectly. And it was a lower total cost than the old traditional merchant account. Make sure you look at total costs, no matter what solution you investigate!
 |
| The iPad with the Square reader and Square App. |
I spent a lot of time reading through the FAQs at the Square site to be sure I understood their processes. I signed up for an account. They sent me a Square reader, and we converted. The 3-year-old Square reader I had laying around was inconsistent and hard to scan with on the iPad, but worked very well on my Android phone. The new Square reader they sent me was much, much, much easier and more reliable on the iPad.
So far, we have had the iPad app crash three times, out of an estimated 700 transactions. In each case, it happened before the transaction was complete, so we had to re-run those transactions. I completely re-set my iPad, and it has not happened since then.
Because I have those two readers, during our busy days we can have both running at the same time, one on the iPad and one on my phone. Now that is kinda cool.
Customers like it, except for one grumpy guy. The iPad seems high-tech, and the process is easy for customers. There are no more paper receipts because Square will text or email their receipt. A few customers have still asked for a paper receipt, usually just to record the amount. We’ve been able to offer them a piece of adding machine tape with their total, and our stamp on it. So far, no complaints.
The payments are processed quickly, with next day transfer. Payments actually arrive about one day quicker than they did with our old traditional processor. Square is also inching into point-of-sale territory, with the ability to “ring up” cash payments and the ability to connect a printer and cash drawer.
Mobile Payments – Pay With Your Phone
Square offers a mobile payment option, called Card Case. Customers create their own account with Square, then only need to bring their compatible phone with them to complete their payment at the store. I signed us up, and we’ve had one customer pay this way. (Cool!) I did have to experiment a bit to get our address right on the map. Instead of 916 Oklahoma Blvd, I had to put in 916 Okla Blvd to get the map pin in the right place. That matters, because Card Case wants to see that the customer really is at the store before allowing a transaction.
Google Wallet
I also looked into a few of the other new payment systems. Google Wallet requires NFC (Near Field Communications) built into the customer’s phone and an NFC receiver at my store. I might have one customer who has an NFC-enabled phone. So that wouldn’t solve my every-day credit card processing needs.
Intuit GoPayment
I looked at Intuit GoPayment, but they still have a more complex fee structure than Square. Most cards are 2.70% with no transaction fee. American Express cards are treated differently, and there are “non-qualified rates” in the fine print. That deserves careful reading and understanding before making any commitment.
I give big credit to Intuit for improving. Their fee structure is now much less complex than it used to be, and their offer of a better rate for high-volume merchants might make a big difference. It’s clear they are working hard to be as easy as Square, but they need to keep streamlining. Make it easy for people to compare total costs, Intuit.
GoPayment’s hardware choices have also improved since their introduction. The iPad is listed as a compatible device, however, my particular HTC phone was not. I also found the sales pages lacking in detail and the FAQs harder to navigate, compared to Square. Still, I have to say that GoPayment looks much better than my old traditional merchant account.
Dwolla Isn’t for Credit Cards
A new mobile payment system, Dwolla, is based on cash instead of credit cards. I applaud that. It does require both the customer and the merchant to have an account. Then the customer initiates the transaction, instead of the vendor. It is going to take time for this to reach critical mass in my small town, but I would bet on this ahead of NFC. So I’ll probably set up an account for us soon, out of support for the project more than out of business practicality.
New to SmallBizSurvival.com? Take the Guided Tour. Like what you see? Get our updates.
- Improving Rural Housing: turning blighted dilapidated houses into new homes - May 7, 2021
- Are marijuana shops good or bad for small towns? - April 22, 2021
- Downtown is your town’s core: How to make your case - February 22, 2021
- Zoom Towns: attracting and supporting remote workers in rural small towns - December 10, 2020
- In an economic crisis, spend your brainpower before your dollars - November 25, 2020
- Video: How to fill empty car dealership buildings for the holidays - November 6, 2020
- How has 2020 changed the challenges rural small towns face? Tell us here - October 20, 2020
- The Idea Friendly Method to surviving a business crisis - October 6, 2020
- Join me for the Rural Renewal Symposium online Oct 13 - September 26, 2020
- Cheap placemaking idea: instant murals - September 11, 2020
Love the concept of Dwolla I have an account and they just announced free, no fees for transactions under $10. I think longer term they have a very interesting game changing model.
I live in Des Mines where Dwolla started, so I’ve seen first-hand how hard they’ve worked to make it a convenient, reliable, easy payment alternative. I think it’s definitelt a viable solution for my customers + I believe a lot more will use it as they unveil more and more features. I switched to Square as soon as they opened it to iPad (had it for a year, but worried customers would balk at signing a phone for their purchases). With the ability to now use it as a complete POS, I think it’s the best choice for small businesses – especially when you add in fees, the cost of Lightspeed and the cost of peripherals. Want to know figure out how to QR code items to have them automatically scan and be entered into a spreadsheet or other filing program.
Here’s a follow-up, about how Square saved our business from a major outage today.
What a fantastic writeup, Becky! Not that I’m surprised—you’ve been Doing It Right for so long, I can’t imagine you doing it any other way. Bookmarking to delicious immediately.
Just received an email with the heading “Square rate too high?” It’s a traditional merchant processor advertising their low swiped rate. No word on their monthly fees, add-on fees, statement fees, etc. In fact, be sure you find out your effective rate, not just the swiped rate. Because those two are very, very, very different things.
I also notice this company is trying to make their name sound similar to Intuit’s respectable GoPayment. I give the email three out of four stars for a scummy solicitation trying to take advantage of small businesses. Be wary!
We switched to Square about 18 months ago and love it. I am saving HUGE every day I process with Square. The banks and traditional processors are on a campaign against this truly disruptive technology and game changer. I’ve had many clients tell me their bank said, “Don’t switch to Square because…” and then proceed to give any number of false statements, half truths or other reason not to take your business elsewhere.
I do believe that Sqaure’s lifespan is going to be short lived though…that is until someone else comes up with something even better. In the mean time, I saved about $15,000 last year by switching!!!
I blogged about my experience here – http://www.coffeegroot.com/2011/12/how-to-guaranteed-slash-your-processing-fees-in-half/.